Basic clues to button identification from a button dating chart by Stanley J. Olsen entitled "Dating Early Plain Buttons By Their Form", American Antiquity, Volume 28, Number 4, April 1963. Pictorial handout.
1700-1765 - Roughcast brass or bronze button with hole drilled in shank
1700-1790 - Silver front, bone or wood back, holes for gut fastening
1760-1790 - Cast white metal, iron wire eye, mold seam and plug
1760-1785 - Cast white metal or brass, brass wire eye, burr edge, spun back
1750-1812 - Cast white metal, eye and button are one piece
1812-1830 - Two piece pressed brass button, brass eye soldered to back
1785-1800 - Brass or bronze button, brass eye, soldered, no foot to eye
1812-1820 - Brass or bronze, restrike anvil seam, brass eye with foot soldered to back
1830-present - Two piece pressed brass button, brass eye soldered to back
1750-1830 - Center hole to index turning tool, bone
1800-1860 - Cast white metal, one piece
Post-1870 - Pressed steel, two-piece